Lame
claire light

is thankful all the feasting is over.

email your friends about this site

share

follow this author

subscribe

send a message to this author

contact

reward this author with a star!

stars

follow this author

subscribe

Home

go to your pnn homepage

Start_blogging

start blogging

Helpinappropriate content
LOGIN LOGOUT Home
Politics
news, views
Green
all eco, all the time
Family
well, you know
Diversions
Your daily dose
Style
it's gotta be cheap to be chic!
World
Going global
Wellness
body and soul
Relationships
working them out - or not
Living
the good, the bad, the messy
Etc.
everything else
Food & wine
Full of bite!
Girls' Nights Out
go ahead, mingle!

Image

Using the Bechdel Test

Posted by claire light Posted on: 07/25/08

Using the Bechdel Test

I came across another use of the Bechdel Test in my blog reading today. (I lost track of where I came across it, so sorry to whomever I'm not hat-tipping.)

The Bechdel Test checks the essential misogyny of a film (or book, or television show, or any other narrative. It has three simple points. To pass the test the film must:

  1. have two named female characters who
  2. talk to each other
  3. about something other than a man.

I've known about the Bechdel Test for a while now, but for some reason, I've never applied it to my favorite narratives. So let's do that:

  • Battlestar Galactica passes with flying colors. This is why its the best show on TV
  • Carnavale also passes with zero trouble.
  • Ditto Six Feet Under.
  • Ditto Dexter.
  • Ditto The Sopranos.
  • Deadwood, surprisingly (given its strong female characters) barely squeaks by with a Bechdel conversation perhaps once per season.
  • Donnie Darko almost fails (I think I remember Mom Darko talking to the evil, brainwashed teacher about her daughter.)
  • Harold and Maude fails! Sob!
  • Obviously, Thelma and Louise is made of Bechdel, although now that I think about it, a suprising amount of their dialogue is about a man or men in general.
  • My Beautiful Laundrette fails! Double sob!
  • Unbreakable fails! Heartbreak!
  • Most heartbreaking of all: the quintessential Gen X chick flick, Say Anything, would fail but for one or two character-building scenes in which Diane Court talks to an elderly resident of her father's nursing home.
  • Lessee, what about other superhero movies? The Spiderman franchise fails miserably, So do X-Men (although the men the women talk about are often the bad guys and these are professional conversations, but still), Batman reboot, Hulk, Iron Man ... ugh, I want to stop now. We'll see what happens when Watchmen comes out, if that incredibly important, but lone, scene between the two Silk Spectres will be kept or trashed.
  • Racking my brain for favorite films that pass and it's really hard. But here's an interesting one: Pitch Black, the original Vin Diesel Riddick movie. Of course, Chronicles of Riddick fails effortlessly. But then, Riddick wasn't the protagonist of Pitch Black. The protag was the Radha Mitchell character. Great movie.


Okay, that's enough from me. Now you. What are your favorite movies/TV shows and how do they fare with the Bechdel Test?


4Vote!
Comments (3)

Like this story? Share the news by clicking below:
This is a permanent link to this article. A great way to save it.
PermaLink
Post your article on Digg and let others vote on it.
Digg
Technorati is a blog indexing site.
Technorati
del.icio.us is a social bookmarking site.
Delicious
Kirtsy is a social bookmarking site featuring voting.
Kirtsy_addicon
  • My most recent obsession, Northern Exposure, passes, but not as cleanly as I would have thought. There are so many strong women characters in this show that I thought it would have passed with flying colors, but I can't think of oodles of (important) scenes in which they talk to each other without a man partaking in the conversation as well. Shouldn't they be commended for showing such strong and interesting women, even if men are around too? Am I missing part of the point of the test. On a separate note, Gilmore Girls passes with flying colors.
    By cereals on July 25, 2008 17:53

  • Cool article, by the way. It was fun to mentally my favorite shows through the test. : )
    By cereals on July 25, 2008 17:55

  • well, part of the point of the test is that women aren't there to be bolsters for the male characters. a hot woman hanging on a male character gives him stature, but a hot, interesting, STRONG woman hanging on a male character can give him a LOT of stature, if it's clear that she's there to be a foil for him. so the point of the bechdel test is not just do they have interesting women characters, but do they have interesting women characters who are there for themselves and not just there to give stature to a male character.
    By claire light on July 26, 2008 03:49

Leave a Comment


about us | contact | terms | privacy | goodies | advertise | help | press | feedback